Counsel for the landlord · Paul H. Starkman & Calvin Zhang
The landlord obtained judgment for over $90,000 in unpaid rent, an order for possession and dismissal of the tenants’ damages action.
Read the court’s reasons (PDF)The dispute
The tenants had stopped paying rent on a Markham home. Five days after the landlord served a notice for non-payment in May 2023, the tenants started an action. They sought more than $5 million in damages, alleging that conditions in the home had caused health problems and damage to their belongings. By September 17, 2026, the unpaid rent totalled $129,306.98.
Spectralab counterclaimed for arrears and sought possession. The tenants also moved for summary judgment and sought $476,000 to replace belongings and relocate. The court heard both motions on September 23, 2026.
How the court decided the motions
The first question was where the rent claim could be heard. The arrears exceeded the Landlord and Tenant Board’s $50,000 monetary jurisdiction. Justice de Sa held that section 207(2) of the Residential Tenancies Act allowed the Superior Court to decide the claim and exercise the powers available to the Board (paragraph 20).
The second question was whether the tenants’ allegations required a trial. A City of Markham inspection found no unsafe building condition, and the tenants provided no expert report linking their alleged health problems to the property. The judge found that the tenants had withheld rent and deducted repair expenses without authorization. The evidence allowed the court to decide the claims on summary judgment (paragraphs 21–34).
The order
Justice de Sa granted summary judgment to Spectralab for the outstanding rent, terminated the tenancy and dismissed the tenants’ action. The amount payable was $90,514.89 after a 30% abatement for deficiencies in the property.
The order required the tenants to vacate by December 7, 2026. If they failed to do so, the sheriff was directed to give the landlord vacant possession on that date. The judge invited written submissions on costs (paragraphs 35–43).
What the decision illustrates
- The amount claimed can determine the forum. Here, the landlord’s arrears exceeded the Board’s limit, bringing section 207(2) into play.
- Maintenance records and independent inspections can help a court distinguish a repair issue from a claim that a property is uninhabitable. Evidence connecting the alleged loss to the property mattered on these motions.
- A landlord seeking both money and possession should address each remedy. This order specified the amount of the rent judgment, the date to vacate and the sheriff’s authority if the tenants stayed.
Discuss a rent-arrears claim
A landlord facing a damages action alongside mounting arrears may need the court to address both possession and payment. Our landlord and tenant litigation team can review the lease, rent ledger, notices and repair records to assess the available remedies.
Legal foundation
Justice de Sa applied section 207(2) of the Residential Tenancies Act, 2006 on jurisdiction and sections 59 and 69 on termination for non-payment. The reasons discuss Hryniak v. Mauldin, 2014 SCC 7 on summary judgment and Shearer v. Oz, 2024 ONSC 1723 on unilateral deductions from rent. This account is drawn from the court’s reasons in file CV-23-00002357-0000.